Wednesday, February 06, 2008

The bunk that is alternative medicine.

As well as doing a module in Microbial genomes and Immunology I am also doing a Pharmacology module this semester and my shiny new pharmacology textbook arrived today. I was happy to see the following piece of text in the book.


Modern medicine relies heavily on drugs as the main tool of therapeutics. Other therapeutic procedures such as surgery, diet, exercise, etc, are also important of course, as is deliberate non-intervention, but none is so widely applied as drug based therapeutics.
Before the advent of science-based approaches, repeated attempts were made to construct systems of therapeutics, many of which produced even worse results than pure empiricism. One of these was allopathy, espoused by James Gregory (1735-1882). The favoured remedies included blood letting, emetics, purgatives, which were used until the dominant symptoms of the disease were suppressed. Many patients died from such treatment, and it was in reaction against it that Hahnemann introduced the practice of homœopathy in the early 19th century. The guiding principles of homœopathy are:

- like cures like
- activity can be enhanced by dilution.

The system rapidly drifted into absurdity: for example, Hahnemann recommended the use of drugs at dilutions of 1:10^60, equivalent to one molecule in a sphere the size of the orbit of Neptune.
Many other systems of therapeutics have come and gone, and the variety of dogmatic principles that they embodied have tended to hinder rather than advance scientific progress. Currently, therapeutic systems that have a basis which lies outside the domain of science are actually gaining ground under the general banner of ‘alternative’ or ‘complementary’ medicine. Mostly, they reject the ‘medical model’, which attributes disease to an underlying derangement of normal function that can be defined in biochemical or structural terms, detected by objective means, and influenced beneficially by appropriate chemical or physical interventions. They focus instead on mainly subjective malaise, which may be disease-associated or not. Abandoning objectivity in defining and measuring disease goes along with departure from scientific principles in assessing therapeutic efficacy and risk, with the result that principles and practices can gain acceptance without satisfying any of the criteria of validity that would convince a critical scientist, and that are required by law to be satisfied before a new drug can be introduced into therapy. Public acceptance, alas, has little to do with demonstrable efficacy.

- Excerpt from H.P. RANG, M.M. DALE, J.M RITTER, R.J. FLOWER - RANG and DALE’S Pharmacology Sixth Edition.


markie said...

you don't know what you don't know.

Steven said...

Why type such a tautological statement?

markie said...

and what have you done today to insult your beta estrogen receptors???

genesgalore. said...

the practice of medicine is often as much art as it is science. take Chrohn's disease. standard practice has been corticosteroids followed by inflixinab and azathioprine. reverse the order and the outcome is different.

Steven said...

Don't be silly. Medicine should be based on sound science. Then you know it works. If someone practices medicine like art they are playing with peoples lives.

Giving 3 drunks in a different order doesn't mean homoeopathy works. That has nothing to do with homoeopathy.

Generic Viagra said...

Thank you! Your help is appreciated, Very very interesting article. Thanks for collecting and providing so much info. I am a 54 year old man and I had problems of erectile dysfunction but it already was a stage closed in my life but I find the solution, I bought generic viagra in Online Pharmacy the is the best option to buy Viagra you only must go to the computer and ready!! Be happy and do happy your wife The unsatisfactory sex makes the woman feel inadequate. Choose Generic Viagra and boost your sex-life into the orbit!!!

Joann L said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Joann L said...

Excellent information about alternative medicine I'm very interesting in this topic because I'm trying to find an alternative for don't use Generic Cialis

dyangelo said...

every body buy Viagra Online because this pill cure the impotence take it and you're bed problems will disappear with this medication you will have and erection for hours i used and the effect last in my for 27 hours and in some cases last more :o :D :lol: 8-)